build a mortgage intake form it needs to take user informati

· The Verdict ·

“This is a feature request, not a startup idea.”

— Garry Tan

Lead reviewer

Strengths

Mortgage eligibility is a real and common consumer need
Digital intake has genuine friction worth solving

Concerns

No startup thesis here — this is a dev task description
Zero market differentiation from dozens of existing tools
No founder angle, wedge, or demand evidence presented
Reads like a prompt to a contractor, not a pitch to investors

Reasoning

This isn't a pitch — it's a one-sentence feature spec. There's no articulation of who the customer is, what's broken about existing mortgage intake flows, or why this team would win. Mortgage tech is a brutally competitive space full of well-funded incumbents. Without a specific wedge, a non-obvious insight, or any demand signal, this is just noise.

Other judges

Gary Vee

Attention & distribution

01/10

“This isn't a pitch — it's a software ticket with no soul.”

Strengths

Mortgages are a real high-intent market with money behind it
Eligibility calculators have clear utility for anxious first-time buyers

Concerns

Zero distribution thinking — not even a whisper of how anyone finds this
No audience identified, no empathy, no human behind the idea
Reads like a dev task, not a business with a reason to exist
No cultural timing angle — hundreds of mortgage tools already exist

▸ Read reasoning

Look — this isn't a startup pitch, it's a feature request. There's no mention of who the customer is, why they'd choose this over Rocket Mortgage or any other incumbent, or how a single human being would ever land on this form. Do the work: figure out who you're serving, where they're already spending their attention, and why you're the one to serve them. Until then, this is just a form.

Tony Robbins

Conviction & standards

01/10

“This is a task, not a vision — where is the founder?”

Strengths

Addresses a real and high-stakes financial process
Mortgage eligibility is a genuine user pain point

Concerns

No founder identity, conviction, or personal stake present
Reads as a dev ticket, not a startup pitch
Zero understanding of the user's psychological experience of mortgages
No standard set — no sense of what 'great' looks like here

▸ Read reasoning

This is not a pitch — it is a feature request submitted to the wrong inbox. There is no 'why,' no founder, no sense that anyone has felt this pain personally or decided to build something that matters. What's your why? You cannot raise your standards when no standard has been declared. The market for mortgage tooling is real, but a form with eligibility math is a weekend project, not a company.

Original pitch

build a mortgage intake form it needs to take user information related to a mortgage application and calculate eligibility

Path

·
Submitted
·
Scored

Comments0

Pitch anotherLeaderboard